Example lessons › How do we get velocity and position from motion with changing speed, and how do we apply kinematic equations to free fall?

How do we get velocity and position from motion with changing speed, and how do we apply kinematic equations to free fall?

Calculus-Based PhysicsOne-Dimensional Kinematics

How Socrates teaches: a short explanation when something is new, then a question that leaves the student real work. It builds on what the student actually said, right or wrong.

Based on a real conversation, details changed.

Student

I drove 20 meters in 2 seconds, so my speed is 10 m/s, right? But I was speeding up the whole time, so I'm not sure what that number means.

Socrates

Your arithmetic is right: 20 m in 2 s is an average speed of 10 m/s. That number describes the whole trip, though, not any single moment of it.

Picture a car that starts at a red light and speeds up steadily. Say it covers 20 m in 2 s. At the very start it was barely moving, and at the end it was moving faster than 10 m/s. Its speed kept changing, so the car had many different speeds during those 2 seconds.

Here is a question to think about: if the car was slow at the start and fast at the end, what would its speed be at the exact moment one second in, compared with the 10 m/s average?

Take notesAverage speed vs. speed at an instant
  • Average speed = total distance ÷ total time = $\frac{20\ \text{m}}{2\ \text{s}} = 10\ \text{m/s}$
  • The average describes the whole trip, not any single moment
  • Watch out: when speed changes, the average hides the speed at each instant
Student

Hmm, if it starts slow and ends fast, then at 1 second it would probably be somewhere around 10 m/s? Maybe a little less since it was slow at the start? I think the average over the whole trip is the speed at every moment, though, so it should still be 10 at 1 second.

Socrates

You have two ideas in your answer, and they pull in different directions. Let's test the second one first.

Imagine the car's speed is a ramp: it starts at 0 m/s and climbs steadily to 20 m/s at the 2-second mark. Its average over those 2 seconds is 10 m/s, which matches your 20 m in 2 s.

Now picture a second car that runs at a steady 10 m/s for the whole trip. Its speed is 10 m/s at every moment, so the average and the instant speed are the same.

Here is the question: if the first car was going 0 m/s at the start and 20 m/s at the end, can its speed at the 1-second mark be 10 m/s? Tell me what you think it would show on a speedometer at that moment.

Take notesAverage speed vs. instant speed
  • A steady 10 m/s car has speed 10 m/s at every moment
  • A car speeding up from 0 to 20 m/s over 2 s averages 10 m/s, but its speedometer reads different values at different moments
  • Average ≠ speed at every moment when speed changes
Student

Hmm, if it goes from 0 to 20 steadily, then at 1 second it should be halfway, so 10 m/s on the speedometer? That's the same number as the average. So yeah, I guess the average is the speed at 1 second in this case.

Socrates

You reasoned that the speed climbs steadily from 0 to 20 m/s, so halfway through the 2 seconds it reads 10 m/s. That step is sound. Your conclusion that the average is the speed at 1 second is where I'd push back, though. The two numbers match here only because this particular speed-up is perfectly even. Let's test that idea on a different case.

Picture a car that waits at a red light for 1 second, sitting still at 0 m/s. Then it jumps to 20 m/s and holds that speed for the second second. Over the full 2 seconds it still covers 20 m, so its average is still 10 m/s.

Here is the question: at the 1-second mark, what does this car's speedometer read?

Take notesAverage speed vs. speed at one moment
  • Steady speed-up from 0 to 20 m/s over 2 s: speed at 1 s is 10 m/s, which matches the average
  • Same 20 m in 2 s can come from a different pattern, so the average alone doesn't tell the speed at 1 s
  • Don't assume the average is the speed at every moment
Student

At exactly 1 second it's still sitting at 0 because it only jumps to 20 after the first second. So the speedometer reads 0 at that moment, not 10. So the average isn't the speed at every moment after all. But I still don't really get how to find the speed at one exact instant if it keeps changing.

Socrates

Yes, the speedometer reads 0 at exactly 1 second. The car is still waiting at the light, so the average of 10 m/s tells you nothing about that moment.

Now the instant question. Think about a short window of time right after the moment you care about. Suppose you want the speed at 1 second, and you look at how far the car travels between 1 second and 1.1 seconds. The time for that window is 0.1 s. If the car covers 2 m in that window, what is its average speed over those 0.1 s?

Use the same method as before: distance divided by time.

Take notesSpeed at one instant
  • Average speed over a short window = distance ÷ time for that window
  • Instantaneous speed: make the window smaller and smaller, so the average approaches the speed at that moment
  • Watch out: a window that is too long averages in speeds from other moments
Student

2 m divided by 0.1 s is 20 m/s. So the average speed over that little window is 20 m/s. Is that the speed at 1 second, or is it still just an average?

Socrates

Your division is right: 2 m ÷ 0.1 s = 20 m/s. That is still an average, but over a much shorter window.

Think about what the car is doing in that window. It sits still until 1 s, then jumps to 20 m/s. So between 1 s and 1.1 s it is already moving at 20 m/s, and the average over that window is 20 m/s too.

Now shrink the window further. Suppose you look at the distance covered between 1 s and 1.01 s, which is 0.01 s long. If the car moves 0.2 m in that window, what is its average speed over those 0.01 s?

Take notesShrinking the window
  1. Window from 1 s to 1.1 s: average = 2 m ÷ 0.1 s = 20 m/s
  2. Window from 1 s to 1.01 s: average = 0.2 m ÷ 0.01 s (to be found)
Student

0.2 m divided by 0.01 s is 20 m/s again. So the windows keep giving 20 but they're getting shorter. I think if you shrink the window to nothing, the average becomes the speed at that exact instant, but I'm still not sure how to do that without just plugging in smaller numbers.

Socrates

Your division is right: 0.2 m ÷ 0.01 s = 20 m/s, and the windows of 0.1 s and 0.01 s both give 20 m/s. You have also named the key idea: the window shrinks toward nothing, and the average approaches the speed at that instant.

Plugging in smaller numbers is a good start, and you can do it with a formula instead. Call the window length $\Delta t$ (the Greek letter delta means "a small change in"). If the car's position at time $t$ is $x(t)$, the average speed over the window from $t$ to $t + \Delta t$ is:

$$\frac{x(t + \Delta t) - x(t)}{\Delta t}$$

Think about the car from the red light again. Its position is 0 m until 1 s, then it moves at 20 m/s. Suppose you pick a window that starts at 1 s and ends at $1 + \Delta t$ seconds. What is the car's average speed over that window if $\Delta t$ is any positive number, such as 0.5 s? Tell me what you get, and whether the answer depends on the window length.

Take notesAverage speed over a window
  • Window from $t$ to $t + \Delta t$: average speed $= \dfrac{x(t+\Delta t) - x(t)}{\Delta t}$
  • Instantaneous speed: let $\Delta t$ shrink toward 0

Try it yourself

Ask Socrates a question: five replies, no account needed.